The Best Couples Halloween Costumes (to Prove Your Relationship Isn’t Failing)

From A24-inspired costumes to bowling button-downs that sing, “Woke up this morning and I had some gabagool…”

Oct 6 2021, 11:00am

Props to you, buddy. You’re clearly the better most motivated half of your couple if you’re reading this—or at least the most strategic when it comes to finding the best couple’s Halloween costumes that won’t suck eggs, and also won’t cost you hundreds of dollars. 

The world just doesn’t really need another ketchup-and-mustard duo, does it? You can throw down the same amount of money for a couple’s costume that pays homage to some of the best movies, TV shows, and cult Halloween characters instead, especially now that 90s nostalgia has come full circle and A24 consistently gives us so much creepy-meets-aesthetic cosplay fodder. Remember the H-Ween of Midsommar flower crowns? There was no better way to subtly roast your partner that year than by sticking them in a bear suit. 

This year, we’re looking to some of our favorite David Lynch movies, Woody Harrelson characters, and undying love of Space Jam for inspiration. We’ve got plenty of costumes that you can assemble with just a few strategic Amazon additions (Daria needs her round glasses, after all) or that come fully assembled for the truly lazy, because, same. Whether your relationship is romantic, platonic, or a situationship—the truest fright factor of the fall—here are some of the raddest, unique couple’s Halloween costumes to increase your coolness capital. 

Welcome to the Space Jam

Ah, everyone’s favorite anthropomorphic basketball movie. It’s easy to find already-assembled Space Jam costumes online of Lola and Bugs Bunny, but you can also do a DIY version with some basic basketball fits and bunny ears.
Lola Bunny Costume

$41.99 at Amazon
Space Jam: A New Legacy Sweatband Kit

$36.99 at Amazon

Bunny Ears

$7.99 at Amazon
Sporty Shorts Sports Pants

$11.87 at Light in the Box

Sailor and Lula from 'Wild at Heart'

We’ll take any excuse to create a Laura Dern and Nicholas Cage cosplay moment. David Lynch’s cult 90s movie put these two in soooo many sick outfits, but you’re going to want to go for the looks from the movie poster (and this scene); find a faux snakeskin jacket or button-down for Cage’s character, Sailor, and the pink dress worn by his lady love, Lula (played by Dern). Perfect a heavy-handed Elvis accent if you’re Sailor, and if you’re Lula, get ready to repeat the line, “This whole world is wild at heart and weird on top” in red lipstick. 

Solid Off-the-Shoulder Bodycon Dress

$10 at Shein
Leopard Snakeskin Print Button Down

$23.98 at Amazon

For all the alt 90s kids, Daria and Jane

This really is the perfect couple’s costume for Gen Xers and older millennials who still have pairs of combat boots floating around. There are loads of pre-made Daria costumes on the web, and you can also find plenty of Daria-ready black glasses and skirts. Her equally iconic BFF Jane isn’t as ubiquitous on the H-Ween circuit, but her look is just as easy to create with a red blazer and the right wig.  

Party City
Daria Morgendorffer Halloween Costume Kit

$49.99 at Walmart

Combat Boots

$11.99 at Amazon

Fashion Magazine
Red Blazer

$17.25 at Amazon

Black Wig

$21.99 at Amazon

You’re an A24 ho

Midsommar has been played out at this point, so why not pay homage to The Lighthouse? Super creepy, and super H-ween appropriate. Just dress up as either Robert Pattinson and Willem Dafoe’s unhinged sailor characters, or Pattison/Dafoe and a seaweed tangled mermaid from *that* scene. Pipe and farting optional, but preferred. 

Winchester Fake Moustache

$15.99 at Amazon
Wedding Suspenders

$11.50 at ASOS
Simple Baker Boy Cap

$7 at Shein

Faux Seaweed

$18.98 at Amazon
Mermaid Tail

$18.95 at Amazon

Mickey and Mallory Knox

The cult 90s movie Natural Born Killers follows the misadventures of a psychopathic, serial killer couple, which means it was basically made for Halloween. Why else would the film’s stylist have given Woody Harrelson’s character, Mickey, those red-tinted shades, or Juliette Lewis (who plays Mallory) such a rad crop top? For Mickey’s most iconic look, all you need is an all-white ensemble, a chonky belt, some fake blood, and those red shades.

Athletic Works
Quick Dry Short Sleeve T-Shirt

$6.88 at Walmart
Slim Chinos

$29 at ASOS

Fake Blood

$17.99 at Amazon
Polarized Round Sunglasses

$12.99 at Amazon

If you’re dressing up as Mallory, you can either go for her sundress “marriage” scene outfit, or her low-rise pants and crop-top combo:

Low Rise Drawstring Pant

$25.10 at Amazon
Women’s Crop Top

$9.89 at Amazon
Wednesday's Girl Mini Cami Dress

$9.60 at ASOS

For a super easy costume, do Georgie and Pennywise

You could really pull this off with the bare minimum of a yellow raincoat for Georgie, and some Pennywise face paint/a mask for your creepier, better half. If you do want to add in a few more finishing touches, recreate Georgie’s boat toy with some paper, and give the clown a ruffled shirt. 

Pennywise Mask

$24.99 at Amazon
Ruffle Trim Solid Blouse

$22 at Shein
Custom Leathercraft
Yellow Raincoat

$15.88 at Amazon

Woke up this morning and you had some gabagool

Everyone is losing it with opinions over The Many Saints of Newark right now, and will be for the rest of October. No matter what you thought of the latest ~Soprano story~ we can all agree that prima di tuuuuutti, the most iconic duo from the franchise, next to Tony and Camilla, is Tony and his [gestures in Italian] gabagool. Also, we will use any excuse to invest in more Sicilian mobster-appropriate bowling shirts (though you might need to trim your wig down a bit). 

Brown Balding Mens Wig

$28.99 at Walmart
Abercrombie & Fitch
Relaxed Cotton Button-Up Knit Polo

$55.00$26.99 at Abercrombie & Fitch

TBH the gabagool has the coziest fit for the eve:

Meat Print Tracksuit

$17.41 at Wish

Wishing you and yours a bloody, fruit-by-the-foot-filled H-Ween. 

The Rec Room staff independently selected all of the stuff featured in this story.  


Halloween, Sopranos, couples, halloween costume

like this
It's 2022 and Suits Are Boring—Here's What to Wear to a Wedding Instead
How to Find the Best White Tank Top
Turtlenecks Are the Horniest Winterwear
The Best Sunglasses for Looking Hotter Than Your Best Friend's Mom
The Best Bathrobes for Lounging, Getting the Mail, and Staying Cozy
The Coolest New Drops This Week, From PlayStation Sneakers to V-Day Coffee
The Best Denim Jackets for Women (Who Take No Prisoners)
Crocs Have Been Raising Hell for 20 Years, and the Haters Can Cry About It