How to Find the Best White Tank Top

From the dollar store to influencer-loved brands, I tested the gamut of ribbed, white tank tops to find my dream rotation for a sexy Cameron Poe vibe.

Mar 31 2022, 7:50pm

As New York City starts to warm up, I know I can look forward to a lobster pot of sweat, poppers, and rogue AC unit drips. I love it. I fear it. I need to be better equipped for it, as a Californian who just moved to Brooklyn who is still learning the ropes of Heattech, rolling carts, and flirting with your bodega cat. 

This city moves fast [Sinatra jazz hands], but it moves even faster in spring and summer. Despite the rising humidity, the those months always have me peeling out of the house for a drink/bike ride/park jaunt more than the holed-up winter months. The sartorial result? A series of quick-grab looks that live on my floordrobe like a whale carcass, amassing more and more socks and fanny packs and building out my summer avatar with bike shorts, button-ups, socks and sandals, and other essentials. Yet, the piece around which all others orbit—the one at the very core of that warm weather avatar—is the basic white tank top. Or rather, my best white tank top.

Advertisement

I’ve made it my personal mission over the past few months to find the best white tanks; the ones that feel unisex, super thin and ideal for layering; the ones you can wear to an elegant, swankity cocktail shindig; and the ones that are thick, long, cuttable, and forgettable. I’ve tried everything from the dollar store ribbed fit to a $75 white tank top that makes me feel like a Parade underwear-hawking micro-influencer—and I’ve also fallen for a few underdogs along the way.  

Here’s the breakdown of my USPIS-backed (nope) research in my quest for the best white tank top.  

The safe choice

This is where the mission began: It was May, and it just started to get hot. Knowing nothing about what I wanted in a tank, I ordered a four-pack of Hanes from Amazon because I knew the brand and trusted that it wouldn’t be trash. I love that these white tank tops are tagless and shrink a bit in the wash, because I like my ribbed tees tyte. They’re a little short for my long-bean torso (I’m 5’10’’), but if you’re a medium-to-short bean, you’ll have no issues. The collar is a little thin for my taste, but if you’re into that, rock n’ roll. You probably won’t see these tanks on the runway any time soon, but they’re classic, dependable, and won’t break the bank. 

Hanes
Men’s White Tank (4 pack)

$21.72 at Amazon

Hanes also makes a set in some classic earthy colors (I can’t wait to pair the olive green with my wide-leg cargo pants).

Hanes
FreshIQ ComfortSoft Dyed Tagless Tanks (4-Pack)

$33.89 at Amazon

The softest one by far

The rad thing about this tank from Richer Poorer is that it comes in eight earthy colors, and the olive shade makes me feel like Laura Croft. At $38 (or a two-pack bundle that’s on-sale right now), it’s definitely on the pricier side for basic white tank tops, but you’re paying for quality—it won’t get distorted in the wash, it’s mad soft, and the fabric has a weight and thickness to it that makes me feel both richer and more well-read (and, as one bud told me, also supports bigger boobs, too). It hits right below my navel (so, SFW and the family function) and will definitely be taking me into fall more than any other tank on the list.  

Richer Poorer
Women’s Vintage Rib Tank

$38 at Richer Poorer
Richer Poorer
Women's Vintage Rib Tank 2-Pack

$72.00$62 at Richer Poorer

Tony Soprano is your style icon

My search almost stopped here. That’s how much I love a basic, tagless white tee by Fruit of the Loom, which I often buy in packs from one of my favorite dollar stores on Knickerbocker Avenue in Bushwick. They must be super thin if you’re going for a Zoë Kravitz nipple moment, but have a thick collar situation that my friends always say “makes it look more expensive than it is.” I usually cut these babies to varying degrees of midriff tops, use the scraps to clean my windows, and wear them out on hikes, dates, or running errands when I want to feel like a hot, 65-year-old Italian dad on a mission for his sopressata. 

Fruit of the Loom
Men's A-Shirt Multi-Pack

$9.99 at Amazon

If you like a high collar

So, OK. I bought these while riding the Fruit of the Loom high, and they’re a solid addition in my quest for the best white tank top. They do a lot of what the other budget white tees on this list do, but have a slightly higher collar—which I love. The pits feel a little low for me, though. IDK. At this point, I started to wonder if Fruit of the Loom ruined all other ribbed tees for me. [Stares wistfully out of subway window.] 

TZ Promise
Men’s White Ribbed Undershirt (6 pack)

$18.99 at Amazon

The best deconstructed white tank

Here’s the FoTL (lol) tank’s biggest contender, about neck-in-neck to the Richer Poorer tank. The Line by K is a brand by blogger and vintage sleuth Karla Deras, who was one of the internet’s first proto-influencers. Deras would thrift pieces, cut them up, and find effortlessly sexy ways of arranging them with vintage and high-end pieces. The Line by K launched in 2015 with the goal of creating basics that aren’t basic, such as this white ribbed tank. The “Ximeno” is like a backwards men’s racerback that’s soft and has flattering side-tailoring, a high-neck, and a deconstructed back that makes it more swank than the rest on the list. The unique tailoring in the back means that it slides over your boob if you’re moving around a lot, but otherwise, it’s rad. Wish it was a bit more affordable, but there’s legit no other tank out there like this, and it’s on-sale right now.

The Line by K
Ximeno Tank

$75.00$45 at The Lobby

Let me know which ones tank for you? (I’m so sorry.) Blessings. 


The Rec Room staff independently selected all of the stuff featured in this story. 

Tagged:

Evergreen, T-Shirt, Tony Soprano, tank top, Tanktops, undershirts

More
like this
The Best Summer Shirts for Men for Adding Some Sauce
The Best Makeup for Men (That Looks Like No Makeup At All)
The Best Denim Jackets for Women (Who Take No Prisoners)
In Defense of Chinos, the Best Pants for Indecisive Men
The Best Water Shoes of the Summer Will Save Your Sole
Toes Out, Boys: The Best Sandals for Men (Who Aren't Cowards)
What VICE Readers Bought This Month: Massagers, Maldon Salt, and Mattresses
The Coolest New Drops This Week, From PlayStation Sneakers to V-Day Coffee