The Best Personalized Valentine's Day Gifts, From Jewelry to Engraved Steak

Show your boo you’ve been paying attention with personalized albums, donuts, board games, sex toys, and more for Valentine’s Day.

What’s better than a donut on Valentine’s Day? Eight donuts that spell out “I love you,” placed on a Swarovski-studded platter and served to your boo after she’s scarfed down a tomahawk steak with the words “MARRY ME, BRENDA??” engraved into the side. Customization has come a long way since the Gutenberg Bible, baby, and there’s no better time to take advantage of humanity’s inanso ability to individualize absolutely everything than with a personalized Valentine’s Day gift. 


The best custom Valentine’s Day Gifts run the gamut from personalized board games and classy photo albums (never not in style), to jewelry that is sweet—but not tacky—and cookware that comes with a personal touch. We’ve found personalized sex toys for spicing things up on those black silk sheets, custom-painted leather jackets, Carhartt tool bags, and so many other ways of saying I <3 YOU.  

Photo albums will always slap

Nothing shows how much you’ve been clocking the important moments with your Valentine quite like a beautiful, tangible collection of curated pictures in a linen-covered photo album with up to 50 pages for your cherished memories. Plus, Artifact Uprising is offering a special 15% off on photo books for a limited time, so get in there while you can. 

Artifact Uprising
Everyday Photo Book

$62 at Artifact Uprising

Say “I love you” with steak

You can’t beat this meat, baby. Pat LaFrieda Meat Purveyors are third-generation meat slingers from New Jersey, and they’ve got a 40-ounce tomahawk steak with your lover’s name on it. 

Pat LaFrieda
Custom Engraved USDA Prime Black Angus Tomahawk Steak (40 oz)

$172.10 at Pat LaFrieda

They’re the Homer to your Marge

Angel Food Bakery is one of Minneapolis’ best bakeries, and beloved for its personalized, custom-message donuts and its iconic Bourbon Caramel Donut Bread Pudding.

Angel Food Bakery
I Love You Donuts

$85 at Goldbelly

For the couple that loves board games

A personalized four-across game to commemorate whatever anniversary is dearest to your heart, from the first time you kissed to that time your partner fought a swole kangaroo at that open air animal park. 

Kasey and Justin Pearson
Personalized Hearts Four-Across Game

$85 at Uncommon Goods

The best personalized jewelry

Hang this personalized silver heart on a chain, pin, or whatever is your hunny’s pleasure. Catbird is the GOAT when it comes to minimalist jewelry, and its sterling silver pendant is a sweet take on a V-Day classic.

Full Heart Charm

$40 at Catbird

A personalized notebook

Is your SO an aspiring poet? A writer of limericks, sketch artist, or a hard-to-shop-for Virgo who’s obsessed with making lists? If so, they’ll appreciate a personalized journal and cool planner for keeping their flashes of genius—or at least their grocery list—organized.

Full of Heart Notebook

$26.99 at Papier

They’re kind of a tool bag, but they’re your tool bag

Embroider this Carhartt tool bag with any two-line personalization you want, so everyone else on the job site will know that they’re DADDI’S KINKEE BB. 

Embroidered Tool Tote

$109.99$82.49 at Personalization Mall

Personal tidings from the host of The Bachelor

You know who LOVES love? Our man Chris Harrison. For a pretty penny, the iconic host of The Bachelor will create a personalized video message for your boo. “Chris exceeded all expectations,” writes one reviewer, “He made it SO special. Cameo only allows you to type 250 characters max, so I didn’t even get to tell him much, but his video seems like he’s known them for years.” What a pro. 

Personalized Video Message from Chris Harrison

$350 at Cameo

‘Til plug do us part

What better way to pop the question than with a personalized sex toy? This silver anal plug comes as a cute ring, and in a very accessible size for butt stuff beginners and ~seasoned~ players alike.  

99 Supplies
Customized Butt Plug

$16 at Etsy

They’re your ride-or-die

“See? I love you more than my Camel Crushes, baby. It says so on this jacket.”

NN Creations Studio
Custom Painting on Your Leather Jacket

$350 at Etsy

The best personalized gift for chefs

Whether they’re a legit chef or just someone who likes to garnish everything with Maldon salt and a sprig of something green, your food-loving boo will appreciate a personalized cast iron skillet from Smithey Ironware, who make some of the best cast iron skillets out there.  

Smithey Ironware Co.
No. 8 Chef's Skillet

$100 at Smithey Ironware Co.

Sock it to them

Yes, it really is as easy as uploading a picture of your face onto socks. You’ll be that much closer to their feet, which is always your goal as their sole discerning lover. 

Custom Face Socks

$12.99 at Amazon

A massive, cardboard cutout of your face

Your love will arrive home after an exhausting day at work, and from the corner of their eye they see your shining face—somehow, even though you live 400 miles away—in the form of a three-foot-tall cutout peering out from behind the bed. Romance ain’t dead, even if Ben Affleck did act TRÈS rude to that lifesize cutout of Ana de Armas. 

Build a Head Shop
2 Foot Huge Head Cutout

$22.99 at Etsy

Wishing you and yours a tasty, romantic, pleather-filled V-Day. 

The Rec Room staff independently selected all of the stuff featured in this story.


Valentine's Day, Evergreen, Gifts, The VICE Valentine's Day Gift Guide

like this
The Best Last-Minute Mother’s Day Gifts That Say, 'I Bought This Ages Ago'
Our Favorite Black-Owned Brands to Support on Juneteenth (and Always)
Last Minute Father's Day Gifts That Won’t Let Him Down (for Once)
What to Buy Your Unconventional Mother Figure for ‘Other Mother's Day’
The Best Unique Wedding Gift Ideas, Because Love Is More Than a Toaster
The Best Food Gifts for Father’s Day That Aren't (All) Bacon-Related
The Best Father's Day Gifts for Stoner Dads
The Best Affordable Mother’s Day Gifts (That Feel Spensi and Thoughtful)