The Sphere, Symbol of American Rejuvenation, Is Already Running Into Problems

The Sphere's chief financial officer abruptly left after a reported argument with James Dolan, and the attraction posted losses in its first quarter.
Screen Shot 2023-11-13 at 1
The Sphere is seen during the opening night in Las Vegas, Nevada, on September 29, 2023. (Photo source: Getty Images)

Since its creation, The Sphere in Las Vegas has become, for people of a certain techno-political persuasion, a beacon of hope in a sea of darkness. 

At 875,000 square feet and 366 feet tall, it is the largest spherical structure in the world and able to fit 12,000 people. But it has quickly become better known as the world's largest LED screen, an ever-changing globe of QR codes and smiling cartoon faces that look down on the Las Vegas strip. 


Optimists have described it as  “the future of entertainment,” “the most insane concert venue ever built,” and a representation of modern-day American ingenuity in action. “Late stage empires don’t build things this extraordinary,” Eric Wollberg, the co-founder and CEO at Prophetic, a neurotech startup, wrote in September while reposting a video from inside the venue of one of U2’s first shows. “America bodied y’all. Absolute dominance,” another Twitter user wrote this month alongside a video of The Sphere as a round yellow cartoon figure, casting his eyes down on the people below him.  

Have information on The Sphere? We want to hear from you. From a non-work device, contact our reporter at or via Signal at 310-614-3752 for extra security.

But since The Sphere’s debut on September 29, evidence has begun to pop up that something might be amiss. The chatter started November 3, when the company informed the SEC that chief financial officer Gautam Ranji had quit. In the SEC filing, the company said Ranji’s resignation was “not a result of any disagreement with the Company’s independent auditors or any member of management on any matter of accounting principles or practices, financial statement disclosure or internal controls.”


But four days later, The New York Post insinuated that was not actually the case. A source had told the outlet that Ranji had quit after his boss, the famously ill-tempered Knicks owner James Dolan, reportedly screamed at him during a meeting of senior executives. The Sphere Entertainment Co. is a part of Dolan’s Madison Square Garden empire, though Madison Square Garden Entertainment was spun off earlier this year.

Ranji, who had worked at the company for 11 months, reportedly “calmly” left the room and immediately told the company’s general counsel he was done.

It’s unclear what had precipitated the screaming, but one day after The Post’s story published, The Sphere Entertainment Company announced that it had lost $98.4 million in the previous quarter. The number sounded worse than it was. The fiscal quarter had ended September 30, just one day after the Las Vegas venue opened. In just two U2 shows, it already pulled in $4.1 million in “event-related revenues.” The company pulled in an additional $2.6 million in suite license fees and advertising on the exosphere, which started in September as well.

With a full three months of shows, instead of just a few days, the company could reasonably expect to pull in much more money. It has a long way to go in order to recoup its costs: The project, which was initially announced in February 2018, was originally supposed to cost an estimated $1.2 billion but went far over and ultimately cost $2.3 billion.

Dolan had become more intimately involved in The Sphere’s day-to-day operations since February, when MSG Sphere president Lucas Watson suddenly left the company. After that, Dolan had reportedly taken over “supervision” of the project. 

The Sphere, as it turns out, isn't a new Roman Coliseum, but that most American of things: a business, with squabbling executives, targets to beat, and no guarantees.