Culture

Photos of Chinese Homes Owned By People Who Refuse to Sell

In China so-called "nail houses" are seen as an increasingly successful way to stand up to corrupt developers.

by Talia Slonim
30 August 2019, 5:50am

This article originally appeared on VICE ASIA.

They’re colloquially referred to as a dingzihu, or “Nail House.” These are homes slated for demolition to make way for freeways, shopping malls, or some other state-sanctioned piece of private infrastructure, and the owners refuse to sell or even vacate. In this way the homes resemble protruding “nails” on the landscape that refuse to be hammered down, and demolition workers simply have to work around them. In the end, stubborn residents often find their homes surrounded by parking lots, or roads, but they continue to live there.

1567141049051-2007-12-03T120000Z_612016840_GF2DWSQFBPAD_RTRMADP_3_CHINA
Photo by REUTERS/Paul Yeung. A six-floor vill on the construction site in the central business district of Shenzhen in April 2007. Choi Chu Cheung, the owner of the villa, and his wife Zhang Lian refused to accept the compensation offered by the developer.

"These houses have captured China’s imagination because they represent a ‘David and Goliath’ struggle,” explains Steve Hess, who is an Assistant Professor of Political Science at Transylvania University in Kentucky. He’s spent years studying the phenomenon, and in 2010 published a paper titled Nail-Houses, Land Rights, and Frames of Injustice on China's Protest Landscape.

“They first emerged as a phenomenon in the mid-1990s," he explains via email. “This is when a reform in 1994 shifted many tax revenue sources from local government to the national government.”

What this achieved, Steve explained, was the diversion of money to the central government, leaving local authorities strapped for cash. One solution was for regional officials to start selling land to developers, over which they had jurisdiction. And as they wasn’t obliged to pay market rates to displaced residents, they began making a lot of profit as they resold the properties. Over time this loophole became something of an official scam, which is something residents are today only too aware of.

1567141073724-2016-05-04T120000Z_1061241019_S1BETCEQYHAB_RTRMADP_3_CHINA-HOUSING
Tao Weiren sits in front of his two-story house in Guangfuli neighbourhood in Shanghai in March 2016. On paper, the Guangfuli neighbourhood is a real estate investor's dream: a plot in the middle of one of the world's most expensive and fast-rising property markets. But the reality is more like a developer's nightmare, thanks to hundreds of people living there who have refused to budge from their ramshackle homes. Photo by REUTERS/Aly Song

Today, anyone who refuses to go quickly becomes an enemy of the state. But they’re also increasingly perceived as local heroes.

“Nail house protests really resonate with the Chinese public because of the wide perception that local officials are corrupt and collude with developers,” explains Steve. “The movement has come to symbolise the growing ‘rights consciousness’ within China, as citizens stand up against local officials who are misusing their offices.”

Of course, standing up to Chinese state officials is incredibly dangerous, and many people who refuse to go have been thrown in jail. For this reason, protesters often turn to foreign news organisations and social media to use publicity as a kind of protection, according to Steve. This is a rather new technique though, and for most of the 90s and early 2000s protesters adorned their homes with signs and banners, and even chained themselves to properties to stop demolition crews.

1567141113588-2010-02-10T120000Z_1960809973_GM1E62A174C01_RTRMADP_3_CHINA
A partially-demolished house at a construction site in Hefei, Anhui province in February 2, 2010. The owner of the house was attempting to seek more compensation before agreeing to the demolition of their home. The owner of the nail house reached an agreement with the local authorities and the house was demolished on February 9. Photo by REUTERS/Stringer

“In some extreme cases, citizens have attacked or lobbed Molotov cocktails at construction workers,” says Steve, citing a 2008 case in which a woman from Minhang district of Shanghai hurled explosives made from wine bottles and petrol at demolition workers. In this case the woman was ungracefully arrested—but online she became something of a local hero.

So why is it that people are willing to take such incredible risks, only to be rewarded by retaining a home that ultimately becomes a traffic island? The answers are fiscal as well as emotional. Firstly, as mentioned, movement officials usually pay inadequate compensation to buy similar-sized homes in the same area. More importantly, though, people are increasingly aware that protesting can lead to increased compensation.

Steve is quick to clarify that this doesn’t mean nail house protests constitute a movement, but rather that individual Chinese citizens are increasingly aware of other successful protests thanks to Weibo and WeChat. Additionally, another federal law passed in 2007 strengthened rights of citizens to their land, motivating many to engage in “rightful resistance.” Thanks to these factors, nail houses are becoming more and more common.

1567141137255-2008-10-31T120000Z_140204247_GM1E4AV1D4P01_RTRMADP_3_CHINA
A nail house on the outskirts of Nanjing, Jiangsu province in October 2008. Again, the owners of insisted on more compensation before agreeing to demolition. Photo by REUTERS/Sean Yong

“This phenomenon is still very relevant today,” he says. “Housing costs have gone up, particularly in job-rich urban centres where citizens are very cynical towards local officials—especially amidst Xi Jinping's anti-corruption campaign.”

It’s in these places, he says, that more and more people are refusing to roll their homes over for developers.

Follow Talia on Instagram

1567141164324-2007-11-05T120000Z_1629256266_GM1DWNJWJPAA_RTRMADP_3_CHINA-ECONOMY-PROPERTY
A labourer collects bricks in front of a nail house in the centre of a construction site which will be developed as a new apartment zone in Hefei. Photo by REUTERS/Jianan Yu
1567141180417-2008-01-03T120000Z_2050803663_GM1DWYNWTAAA_RTRMADP_3_CHINA-ROADS
A nail house at a construction site which will be developed into a new apartment zone in Hefei, Anhui province in January 2008. The banner reads "strongly requesting the government to punish the developer who demolished my house, give back my home". Photo by REUTERS/Jianan Yu
1567141199370-2008-01-09T120000Z_2040247967_GM1DWZQRPGAA_RTRMADP_3_CHINA
A nail house remains in a construction site before in Guangzhou. This was taken January 8, 2008, just before the place was finally demolished. Photo by REUTERS/Joe Tan
1567141227166-2012-11-24T120000Z_1898643744_GM1E8BO1C7501_RTRMADP_3_CHINA
An elderly couple refused to allow their house to be demolished, so it became the only building left in the middle of a road their village in Zhejiang province. The place was finally demolished in 2012. Photo by REUTERS/Aly Song
Tagged:
china
Corruption
demolition
highway
Developers
nail houses
dingzihu