Advertisement
Health

Canada Has Finally Killed the Four Food Groups

In the new food guide, Canadians are no longer being told to eat like a World War Two soldier.

by Nick Rose
Jan 22 2019, 8:19pm

Image courtesy of Health Canada. 

In 1942, the government of Canada released its Official Food Rules to ensure that Canadians ate well in an era of wartime rations, malnutrition, economic instability, and limited supplies. It called for the consumption of “health-protective foods” like liver, heart, and kidney once a week and more than a pint of milk per day for children. These highs-stakes, high-calorie “Food Rules” would eventually morph into Canada’s iconic Food Guide, the rainbow of yellow, green, blue, and red plastered on the hallways of our youth.

Seventy-seven years later, Canada’s food rules have been overhauled once again, complete with a Periscope livestream to make the announcement. Speaking from Montreal, Health Minister Ginette Petitpas Taylor made a hip reference to Anthony Bourdain’s idiom that, “Food is everything we are,” adding that the central idea behind the new Food Guide was that “Eating should be a pleasure.” OK, we’re listening.

So, what are the big changes made to Canada’s Food Guide? The most obvious one is the shift away from food groups—the cornerstone of the Food Guide since 1942—and toward how and when we eat.

1548187391138-foodguideline
source: Health Canada

Sure there’s the obvious, like eating lots of fruits and vegetables (referred to as “veggies”), but the Food Guide then goes on to emphasize adequate hydration, calling for lots of water and less alcohol, which contrary to what some millennials might think, are not food groups. Meat is no longer its own category and has been replaced with broader “protein foods,” which includes plant-based alternatives like legumes, as well as lean meats and lower fat yogurt.

Instead of getting caught up with portion guidelines, the Food Guide makes lifestyle recommendations like cooking for yourself, reading labels, eating less processed foods, being more self-sufficient (“Grow, harvest, fish, hunt and prepare food in traditional ways”) and, perhaps most refreshingly, sharing “food traditions, across generations and cultures.”

In other words, it’s out with the confusing portion sizes of yore, like 8-10 servings of vegetables for adult males aged 19-50 versus 7-8 for adult females, and in with learning recipes from your grandparents. And while it sounds like these guidelines were thought up while Petitpas Taylor was watching an episode of Parts Unknown, Canada’s medical community appears to also be embracing this qualitative approach to what was once a quantitative document.

1548191361395-foodguide1
1992 Canada's Food Guide to Healthy Eating, that’s a lot of carbs. Health Canada.

In a press release, Canadian Medical Association (CMA) President Dr. Gigi Osler said that the CMA was “pleased with the federal government's overall direction in the new Food Guide” and “particularly supportive of the evidence-based review and extensive consultation process used to draft the new Guide, to ensure it was founded on unbiased research.”

But not everyone was happy with Health Canada’s new recommendations to “plan a breakfast date with friends” and “5 ways to add flavour to your water.” Like meat products, milk products are no longer a category of their own and the Food Guide calls for lower fat products. Dairy Farmers of Canada, Canada’s might milk lobby, took issue with this downgrade, voicing concerns “that the updated Food Guide does not reflect the most recent and mounting scientific evidence available,” according to a statement issued by their Director of Nutrition and Research Isabelle Neiderer, who added that, “Current and emerging scientific evidence does not support a continued focus on lower fat milk products as it reveals that milk products that contain more fat are not associated with harmful health effects and could even provide benefits.”

To accompany all of these changes, Health Canada even came up with some recipes like moose stew and “Marvellous muffins and we can’t wait for the inevitable candid photo of Justin Trudeau making “Creamy dreamy hummus.”

Follow Nick Rose on Twitter.

Sign up for the VICE Canada Newsletter to get the best of VICE Canada delivered to your inbox.