French elections

What France Would Look Like Under President Marine Le Pen

The far-right leader is likely to be one of the winners in the first round of France's presidential elections this Sunday. But what if she wins the second round, too?

by Ludivine Bénard
Apr 21 2017, 12:22pm

Top image: Still from Marine Le Pen's campaign video

This article originally appeared on VICE France

For a few months now the polls in France have been pretty unanimous: Marine Le Pen will likely get through the first round of presidential elections. Those same polls say she'll be defeated in the second round, but let's imagine for a moment that the unthinkable happens. Let's imagine that at 8PM on the 7th of May, Marine Le Pen is declared the winner of France's presidential elections. What would that mean?

As the new resident of the Élysée Palace – where France's presidents have lived since 1848 – she could turn the country upside down, not just by "restoring a proper musical education in schools" ( which is the 112th point on her 144-point manifesto for the country), but by making changes to the Constitution, having France leave the European Union, re-introducing a French currency and closing the borders. In other words, were Le Pen's ideas actually implemented as they are, everything would change for the French people, French institutions, the European Union and the financial markets.

To find out how bad things could get I asked Nicolas Lebourg, a historian specialising in Le Pen's National Front party, to visit our VICE France office and help us shed some light on this possible future.

Immediately after the election

Usually a new French president is officially inaugurated about ten days after the second round of the presidential elections, and at the latest on the last day of the outgoing president's term – which in this case would be the 14th of May, 2017. Before the 14th, Marine Le Pen wouldn't officially be president – it would be a transitory period in which she can get acquainted with the role and watch financial markets plummet from the sidelines.

If Le Pen is elected, it's almost certain that investors would rush to sell French bonds, fearing the prospect of the country leaving the eurozone and possibly even the EU – or wanting to punish the country for its political choice. Economist Gaël Giraud argues that if that happens, France would only be able to take out loans at significantly higher interest rates. Le Pen knows this situation might be coming, too, so has proposed that the Bank of France be authorised to buy French debt (point 43 of her manifesto) and lend money to the state. That isn't possible now, and could lead to staggering inflation. Externally, investors taking their money out of France and stashing it elsewhere could cause a liquidity crisis for French banks and shake up the economic world order.

Le Pen and the National Front in the general elections

In June, following the presidential election, there's a general legislative election, in which new MPs are chosen for the National Assembly. If a good number of MPs from the new president's party win seats she can count on an absolute majority, which would make governing a lot easier for her. However, as has happened in the past, other parties could work together and form an alliance to make sure the National Front don't gain any more power.

Majority or no majority, the National Front will likely gain a pretty significant number of seats in the Assembly in June if Le Pen is elected president in May. The entire party would ride along on her victorious wave – a presidential win attracts more voters, and potential MPs of another right wing party, Les Républicains, could support her – which could mean a pretty hefty increase in seats. As Le Pen told French newspaper Le Monde recently: "For the last few years we have welcomed people from different backgrounds to our party. Many people will want to join us after the first round of elections, in between rounds and after the second round."


WATCH: VICE Talks Film – Riz Ahmed


Le Pen's first priority: changing the Constitution

During her campaign, Le Pen hammered home that her first objective is to "give the people its voice back". The way she intends to do that is quite high up her list: the second point of her manifesto is to frequently hold referendums, some of which would allow her to change the French Constitution.

Should French voters who didn't elect her be worried about those referendums? According to Lebourg, it would actually give them some power in deciding the direction the country should go in: French citizens could oppose Le Pen's proposals by voting "no" in a referendum. At every referendum the president's reputation would be at stake, as well as the policies she'd want to implement.

Le Pen's second priority: severing ties with the European Union

Marine Le Pen wants to lose EU influence in France faster than you can say "single market". She told Le Monde that, if she wins, she'll hold a referendum immediately after the elections, aiming to, in her words, "enshrine in the Constitution the supremacy of French law over European treaties". With a mandate she plans to go to Brussels to negotiate the things she believes are vital for France's independence: getting their own currency back, no influence from the European parliament in France and complete power over their own budget and territory. It's literally the first point of her 144-point manifesto.

She also has plans for another referendum on whether or not France should stay in the EU six months into her presidency. She has said that if the EU gives her everything she wants in those negotiations – which, you know, isn't likely – she'd urge the French people to stay in the EU. But if she doesn't, she'll campaign to leave the EU.

So how would the French public vote in a referendum on EU membership? There isn't much recent trustworthy data, but in March of 2016 (before the UK voted to leave the EU) 53 percent of French people polled said they did want a referendum, while two months later 45 percent of those polled said they would want to stay, versus 33 percent who'd want to leave. Lebourg tells me that after the British voted to leave "an opinion poll showed that Brexit had made the French more eager to stay in the EU". Sixty-seven percent of polled people at that point said that being a member of the EU was a pretty good thing.

Le Pen's plans for the working class

Many of Le Pen's 144 measures in her manifesto are geared towards the working class. Like her intention to push the retirement age to 60, to revalue the basic pension and to reduce gas and electricity rates by five percent. She thinks the extra money for all those measures can come from cutting costs on immigration and the EU. She points out in her manifesto that she hopes "to re-establish order in French public finances by putting an end to the misspending of public money (particularly linked to immigration and the European Union) and by combatting social and tax fraud". Savings would be made, for example, by withdrawing state medical aid for undocumented immigrants.

Marine Le Pen's enemies are immigrants and not, for example, the financial sector. She doesn't suggest anywhere that extra money can be brought in by taxing multinationals a few percent more. According to her manifesto, all her social plans for the working class would be feasible without increasing taxes, simply by limiting immigration and possibly leaving the EU. Of course, the National Front steers clear of putting an exact figure on the savings they would make. There's not even consensus about that within the party itself; Lebourg tells me that "in 2012, Marine Le Pen estimated that immigration cost us €40 billion. Then, in 2014, she estimated €70 billion, and €100 billion in 2015. At the party's 2016 summer conference, her Secretary-General Nicolas Bay estimated the cost between €25 billion and and €60 billion."

Photo: Claude Truong-Ngoc, via

Le Pen vs. terrorism

In 2012, Le Pen founded the Marine Blue Gathering – a political coalition of several French right-wing and far-right parties. The coalition works as a political bloc, and its main aim is to push for law and order in the country. As soon as she's president, Le Pen wants to recruit 15,000 new policemen and gendarmes (point 13 of her manifesto) to take action against "criminal gangs" and terrorism, which proposes doing in points 29 through 31 by "banning all organisations that have anything to do with Islamic fundamentalism", closing "extremist mosques" and "withdrawing French nationality and banning from the country all dual nationals linked to jihadist channels". Of course, she'd get into some legal trouble trying to apply and enforce those measures.

According to Lebourg, the real building block of her programme – the fight against terrorism – is deeply connected to her ideas on multiculturalism and immigration. When she talks about one issue, her supporters know she's talking about the other as well. According to Lebourg: "For the National Front, terrorism is not just a security issue, but also a cultural issue. That puts the multicultural and multiethnic society we have in France in jeopardy."

What if people want to take to the streets under President Le Pen?

If Le Pen wins the presidency, her victory would certainly lead to major protests throughout France. But could the French people actually influence any of her policies by striking and protesting?

Le Pen has made it clear that she doesn't think there should be any protests as long as France is still in a state of emergency – which is due to expire after the presidential elections. According to Lebourg, "It's obvious that a ban on protests wouldn't be respected by the French at a time like that. She would need to be delusional to ban protests."

While it'll likely be OK to protest, the seventh point on Le Pen's manifesto is to "simplify appeal procedures for victims of defamation and abuse". So if you do decide to take to the streets to protest President Le Pen, make sure not to yell anything too rude about her.

More on VICE:

Marine Le Pen Sure Follows a Lot of White Supremacists

Will the French Election Deliver Europe's Latest Populist Backlash?

What Do Parisian Schoolgirls Think About the Presidential Elections?