birthright citizenship

Trump Wants to Make It Harder For Pregnant Women to Travel to the U.S.

One expert says the move by the State Department is "mostly symbolic and another way to say the U.S. is closed."

by Paul Blest
24 January 2020, 5:24am

AP Photo/Alex Brandon

President Donald Trump has long railed against the principle of birthright citizenship, but it appears his administration has found a way around that pesky 14th Amendment by simply tightening tourist visa restrictions on pregnant women.

A new rule, which the State Department made public today and will officially issue on Friday, will treat visa applicants who are deemed to be coming to the U.S. to give birth like any other visa applicant who’s coming to the country for medical treatment, meaning they must prove they have the means to pay for that treatment.

The rule “establishes that travel to the United States with the primary purpose of obtaining U.S. citizenship for a child by giving birth in the United States is an impermissible basis for the issuance of a B nonimmigrant visa,” and goes on to say that giving birth in the United States is not “a legitimate activity for pleasure or of a recreational nature.”

The rule is designed to combat what the government has labeled “birth tourism,” or the practice of coming to the United States to give birth so the child would become a citizen. While accurate statistics are difficult to nail down, Pew estimated that at least 275,000 undocumented women gave birth in the United States in 2014.

Although the rule doesn't target any particular nationality, it does cite a January 2019 case in which 19 people were charged in connection with three “birth tourism” companies in Southern California in which clients (“mostly from China,” according to a DOJ press release at the time) lied about their purpose for being in the United States in order to give birth.

“This ugly development is ultimately an issue of racial profiling of Asians,” National Asian Pacific American Women’s Forum executive director Sung Yeon Choimorrow said in a scathing statement posted to Twitter. “The Trump administration will go to any lengths to demean immigrant women. Millions of Asian people come to the U.S. to visit their families, and targeting them because of their race or country of origin is discriminatory and wrong.”

READ: A Mexican asylum-seeker killed himself on a bridge to the U.S. after being denied entry

The new rules are likely on questionable legal grounds. Officials at U.S. consulates are barred from asking people whether they’re pregnant, but they'll be forced to make a judgment call anyway, according to the AP.

It’s also an open question of how effective the changes will be; depending on the origin country, B-2 visas are valid anywhere from one to ten years. “It is largely symbolic,” Migration Policy Institute analyst Sarah Pierce told BuzzFeed News, which obtained a draft of the cable earlier this week. “It’s not going to have a huge effect on the issue. This is mostly symbolic and another way to say the U.S. is closed.”

Cover: President Donald Trump speaks during a meeting with Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis in the Oval Office of the White House, Tuesday, Jan. 7, 2020, in Washington. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)

This article originally appeared on VICE US.

Donald Trump
State Department