Ali blazed the path for hip-hop artists, placing vernacular speech in the service of truth, though such speech is always at first seen as a mockery of taste and pedigree. That's true whether the art in question is the sorrowful songs of the slave plantation, the blues of the urban enclave, or the rap of the concrete jungle. Such views didn't just come from black cultural outsiders; they sprang from native speakers as well. Because reading and writing for enslaved blacks was a matter of life and death, it has often compelled black elites and others to favor highbrow instead of gutbucket literacy. Ali, like the rappers who came behind him, fought racial denigration outside black culture and faced class disdain from within.The charm and magic of Ali's incantatory street doggerel is the way it permitted him to call down on Earth the gods of our self-making and our bold self-loving.
It is not that Ali matured and gave up his ferocious social conscience as much as America caught up to his progressive ideas—at least on the question and costs of the Vietnam War, and to a lesser degree, on the racial crises at home. But the country has yet to acknowledge the link Ali drew between racial injustice at home and war abroad, in which people of color are, as Malcolm X put it, "the victims of democracy." Ali boldly built his views about what was happening in any number of "over there's" with a strict attention to what was happening "over here." "Here" and "there" mattered because their different geographies didn't exhaust the common ideologies that underlay their misfortunes. Ali challenged America to face up to its political hypocrisy and to acknowledge its moral shortcomings as the common point of reference in any serious discussion of war and race on both shores.Shedding tears over Ali's death while ignoring the tears of those who suffer today soils Ali's heroic legacy; extolling Ali's courage as a spokesman for truth while pillorying those who dare tell the truth now is a rejection of Ali, too.
In encounters I had with him, Ali performed magic tricks, nearly in defiance of the unmagical, thudding literalism of the decline he suffered in his physical and motor skills. Despite the withering diminishment of the physical gifts for which he was known, and the silencing of the tongue that once flamed with timeless truths, Ali soldiered on and held fast to his beliefs—that Islam brings peace, that blackness brings greater humanity, that protest and resistance bring greater justice.But then America has always been in love with change in reverse, in the safely settled past, not the dangerously changeable present. We prefer our heroes dead or quiet. Ali's silenced tongue surely hurried him into an iconic space that may have been impossible for him to occupy should he have been able to continue to raise his voice against the injustices he spotted. Because the physical idioms of his expression were severely limited, because his fiery declamation was laid waste to by the siege of decline, Ali was forced, instead, to inhabit relative muteness and transform it into an eloquent expression of his humanity—one where suggestion and inference form a grammar of moral communication.Ali's magic feats were a delightful distraction for us both, but his far greater magic was the relentless pursuit of good in the midst of unimaginable suffering. In that sense, he represented the greatest achievements that black men have conjured when facing odds that most might not survive. As much as he meant to the world, as much as he belonged to that world, what he meant to black people, and to black men most of all, can never be measured in merely physical acts alone, but in the imperishable realm where his style of fight and speech were gifts that linger far beyond his mortal disappearance. That may be Ali's greatest magic act of all.Follow Michael Eric Dyson on Twitter.As much as he meant to the world, what he meant to black men can never be measured in merely physical acts alone, but in the imperishable realm where his style of fight and speech were gifts that linger far beyond his mortal disappearance.