Baltimore Is Bracing for the Freddie Gray Trials After a Deadly Summer
Concerns about violence and unrest threaten to derail criminal justice reform as local prosecutors press ahead in their case against six cops charged with the death of the 25-year-old in April.
On Wednesday, a local circuit court judge denied motions to drop the charges against the six officers indicted in the April death of 25-year-old Freddie Gray, and declined to recuse State Attorney Marilyn Mosby from trying the case.
Defense attorneys argue Mosby acted inappropriately when she dramatically announced criminal charges on May 1, but Judge Barry Williams dismissed that argument. He also ruled that each officer should be tried separately.
Next week, another hearing is scheduled to determine whether the trials—set for mid-October—will take place in Baltimore or in another jurisdiction.
The court proceedings come at a fraught time for Charm City. Nationally, the Black Lives Matter movement continues to flex its muscles. Activists held their first national conference in July, have been successfully pressuring presidential candidates to speak more directly about criminal justice reform, and just last week, the Democratic National Convention passed a unanimous resolution in support of the movement.
Locally, Baltimore activists have also continued to organize themselves since the Freddie Gray protests ended in the spring.
Amidst all this, the city has seen sharp increases in homicides over the past several months; 215 had been killed by the end of August, up from 138 at the same time in 2014. Forty-five people were murdered in July alone, the bloodiest month the city has seen since August 1972. Concerns about violence and unrest threaten to derail political momentum around criminal justice reform.
In the days leading up to Wednesday's hearing, the Baltimore Police Department (BPD) cancelled officer leave in order to ensure that as many police officers as possible would be present throughout the day. Some police showed up in uniform, and others dressed in plainclothes to work undercover. Activist Kwame Rose was arrested in the morning, and one officer suffered minor injuries while assisting with the arrest, but by and large the demonstrations were relatively calm. Baltimore native DeRay Mckesson and Johnetta Elzie, both prominent figures within the national Black Lives Matter movement, attended the demonstration as well.
Speaking at an afternoon press conference, Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake said demonstrators were "peaceful and respectful and an example of democracy in action."
Peter Moskos, a former Baltimore City Police Officer and professor at John Jay College of Criminal Justice, says he expects the community protests to remain fairly calm in September, but that "the real shit is going to hit the fan" when the court issues its final verdicts for the officers. Charges range from second-degree assault—a misdemeanor—to the rather unusual charge of second-degree depraved heart murder. Moskos does not expect that the cops will be found guilty.
Though the community response is likely to escalate following the October trials, activists say they plan to ramp up protests relatively soon. Duane "Shorty" Davis, an activist with Baltimore BLOC, a local grassroots organization, told the Baltimore Sun that they're encouraging people to engage in nonviolent acts of civil disobedience over the next two weeks, particularly in the wealthier and whiter parts of town. "We're not just going to go in the black community and wave our hands. We're going to the white communities," he told the paper.
City politics also remain chaotic. Mosby, who has been cleared to continue working on the Freddie Gray case, will be campaigning and fundraising for her own re-election at the same time. Her husband, Councilman Nick J. Mosby, has also announced that he is "seriously considering" a run for mayor. And in July, Rawlings-Blake fired the city's police commissioner, Anthony Batts—citing the rising city violence. "We need a change. This was not an easy decision, but it is one that is in the best interest of the people of Baltimore," she said at the time. The interim police commissioner, Kevin Davis, has been significantly reorganizing the police department over the past two months.
Dayvon Love, the co-founder of Leaders of a Beautiful Struggle, an organization that advocates for the interests of black people in Baltimore, tells VICE that he anticipates "a plethora of politicians and organizations" will try and use the Freddie Gray trials as a way to advance their own personal careers. "So that sucks," he says. In the meantime, his group will continue to push for reforms to the police union contract, which they were doing well before Gray's death. Specifically they have been focusing on changing the Law Enforcement Officers Bill of Rights, (LEOBR), which they see as a significant barrier to transparency and accountability. Other groups, including the NAACP and the ACLU of Maryland, have rallied for similar changes.
The police union, the Fraternal Order of Police, strongly opposes changes to LEOBR and worked hard to fight proposed reforms this past legislative season.
In the face of all the political maneuvering, the city's activists will be waiting on the verdicts to determine whether justice has been served in a case being watched closely by reformers around the country.
Follow Rachel Cohen on Twitter.
- Black Lives Matter
- Freddie Gray
- Criminal Justice
- Vice Blog
- Police reform