FYI.

This story is over 5 years old.

News

Greek Authorities Say Recovered Debris Not From Missing EgyptAir Flight

The Airbus A320 carrying 66 people from Paris to Cairo disappeared over the Mediterranean on Thursday. Egypt's aviation minister said terrorism is more likely than an accident.
Un Airbus A320 EgyptAir comme celui qui a disparu ce jeudi. L'avion photographié avait été détourné vers Chypre, le 29 mars 2016. Photo de Katia Christodoulou/EPA

This story is developing — please check back for updates.

Officials in Greece have said that debris recovered Thursday from the Mediterranean does not belong to the EgyptAir flight that disappeared en route from Paris to Cairo, apparently contradicting an earlier statement by EgyptAir. Earlier reports described the debris as being blue and white — the colors of the airline.

In its statement, EgyptAir had said that the Egyptian Ministry of Foreign Affairs had confirmed that the wreckage came from flight MS804. The airline extended its condolences to the families of the victims, and said that Greek and Egyptian investigators would continue their search for debris.

Advertisement

The Vice President of EgyptAir Ahmed Adel has since walked back claims made earlier to CNN that the wreckage had been formally identified, saying "we stand corrected." Adel said the debris did not belong to the airline's missing aircraft, and that the search for flight MS804 was ongoing.

Egyptian President Abdul Fattah el-Sisi released a statement on Thursday calling on the country's authorities to "intensify the search" for the missing aircraft.

Confirming at a press conference that the EgyptAir flight from Paris to Cairo had crashed with 66 people onboard, French President François Hollande said no hypothesis could be ruled out in regards what had happened. US officials told Reuters that a preliminary analysis of satellite imagery did not appear to indicate there was an explosion onboard the aircraft. Egypt's aviation minister told a press conference that the Airbus A320 was more likely to have been the victim of a terror attack than a technical fault.

"The situation may point, and I say may because I don't want to go to speculations, and I don't want to go to assumptions, like others, but if you analyze the situation properly, the possibility of having a different action or having a terror attack, is higher than the possibility of having a technical [fault]," Sherif Fathi said.

Conflicting reports about the wreckage began when Greek defense sources said a frigate searching for the EgyptAir aircraft had discovered two large floating objects in the sea 230 miles (370 km) south of the island of Crete on Thursday. The objects were spotted close to an area where a transponder signal was emitted earlier, those sources said. Greek officials also said they had found what appeared to be two aircraft life vests.

Advertisement

According to French daily Le Figaro, the Greek Minister of Defense said that "plastic objects and ropes" had been retrieved around 50 nautical miles from the area where the plane's signal disappeared from the radar.

The US Navy also joined the search for the aircraft, dispatching a P-3 Orion aircraft to the area.

Separately, Paris prosecutors said that they were opening an investigation into the matter, while Egypt's general prosecutor has ordered a state security investigation, judicial sources told Reuters. French Secretary of State for Transport Alain Vidalies announced that three investigators as well as a technical advisor for Airbus would be sent to Cairo on Thursday to help with the investigation.

Greece's defense minister told a news conference that the missing airliner had made "sudden swerves" mid-air and plunged before dropping off radars in the southern Mediterranean.

.— Reuters World (@ReutersWorld)19 May 2016

"At 3.39am (local time) the course of the aircraft was south and south-east of [the islands] Kassos and Karpathos," Panos Kammenos said. "Immediately after it entered Cairo FIR [radar coverage area] and made swerves and a descent I describe; 90 degrees left and then 360 degrees to the right."

EgyptAir flight MS804, operated by an Airbus A320 twinjet, had departed Paris at 11.09pm local time Wednesday, headed to Cairo nonstop.

EgyptAir tweeted that the plane, which was traveling at an altitude of 37,000 feet (11,280 meters), lost contact soon after entering Egyptian airspace. The aircraft was carrying 56 passengers, including one child and two infants, and 10 crew. The latter included three people listed as security. Vidalies told reporters that it was "a customary procedure" to have three air marshals on board EgyptAir aircraft.

Advertisement

Earlier EgyptAir had said 59 passengers were aboard, but then revised the figure.

Egypt's Aviation Ministry said 30 Egyptians, 15 French, one Briton, and a Belgian were among the 66 people on board. The airline also stated that the plane was carrying passengers from Iraq, Canada, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Algeria, Sudan, Chad, and Portugal, according to the BBC.

More than 8 merchant ships have already joined the — MarineTraffic (@MarineTraffic)May 19, 2016

UK Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond also confirmed a British passport holder was on board the plane.

Deeply concerned by missing — Philip Hammond (@PHammondMP)May 19, 2016

The crew was experienced, with a captain who had clocked up 6,275 hours of flying experience, including 2,101 hours on the A320, while the first officer had 2,766 hours, EgyptAir said.

According to flight tracking site flightradar24.com, the twin-engine jet was registered with the Egyptian tail number SU-GCC. Several airline fleet-tracking sites indicate that it was delivered new to the Egyptian carrier in 2003, making it a relatively young 13-year old airframe. Modern, well-maintained jets have useful lifespans far in excess of that.

Egypt's state newspaper Al Ahram reported that there had been no distress call from the plane and that the last contact with the pilot was about 10 minutes before the aircraft disappeared.

The New York Times quoted Ehab Mohy el-Deen, the head of Egypt's air navigation authority, as saying that Greek air traffic controllers notified their Egyptian counterparts that they had lost contact with the plane.

Advertisement

"They did not radio for help or lose altitude," he said. "They just vanished."

The plane disappeared from radar screens two minutes after exiting Greek airspace at 3.27am local time (00:27 GMT) on Thursday morning, the head of Greece's civil aviation department said. Greek air traffic controllers spoke to the pilot over the island of Kea, in what was thought to be the last broadcast from the aircraft.

"The pilot did not mention any problems," Kostas Litzerakis, head of Greece's civil aviation department told Reuters.

French Prime Minister Manuel Valls said on Thursday that France is ruling nothing out as to why the plane went missing.

"We are in close contact with the Egyptian authorities, both civil and military. The Egyptian authorities have already sent air reconnaissance teams to the site, and France is ready to help with the search if the Egyptian authorities ask, of course," Valls told RTL radio.

Rescue services from the Egyptian armed forces had initially reported receiving a distress signal at 4:26 am local time (2:26 GMT) from the aircraft, an official from the airline later said in a statement — but this was denied shortly afterwards by the military.

The Airbus A320 family is one of the world's most popular commercial airplanes — with more than 7,000 built, it is second in sales among jetliners only to the Boeing 737. Built by the European consortium Airbus at assembly lines in France, Germany, China and the US, it has been produced in five different models, from the A318 to A321 in order of size. The A320 typically seats 150 passengers and can fly for up to 5,700 km (3,600 mi.) At 2,000 miles, the Paris-Cairo route is well within the airplane's capabilities.

Advertisement

EgyptAir has a fleet of recently built jets and is a member of Star Alliance, the largest airline alliance in the world, alongside giants such as United Airlines, Germany's Lufthansa and Air Canada. Its maintenance and safety procedures are considered on par with Western carriers, although it suffered a major, and controversial, crash in 1999 when a Boeing 767 en route from New York to Cairo plunged into the Atlantic Ocean shortly after departure. That crash, which killed all 217 aboard, was determined by a US investigation to have been caused by the first officer's intentional actions. Egypt authorities dispute that it was a suicide.

The airline's most recent fatal crash occurred in 2002, when a Boeing 737 on approach to Tunis from Cairo hit high ground during a sandstorm, killing 14.

An Airbus A321 operated by Russia's Metrojet crashed in Egypt's Sinai peninsula on October 31 last year, killing all 224 people on board. Russia and Western governments have said the plane was likely brought down by a bomb, and the Islamic State militant group said it had smuggled an explosive on board.

Reuters reported in January that an EgyptAir mechanic, whose cousin joined the Islamic State in Syria, is suspected of planting the bomb, according to sources familiar with the matter.

In March, an EgyptAir A320 flying from Alexandria to Cairo was hijacked and forced to land in Cyprus by a man with what authorities said was a fake suicide belt. He was arrested after giving himself up.

Without any known indications that the crew may have declared an emergency or that the plane was in distress, there is no immediate, credible scenario for what could have brought down the jet.

Follow VICE News on Twitter: @vicenews