Advertisement
Immigration judges in Atlanta denied 98 percent of petitions for asylum last year, according to statistics published by the Executive Office for Immigration Review, part of the Department of Justice. For comparison, the national average for asylum denial was 52 percent in 2015 and only 16 percent in immigrant-friendly jurisdictions like New York City.If asylum applicants don't receive relief, they can face deportation and become priorities for removal—hence the immigration raids.The trend recently led the Huffington Post to label Atlanta "one of the worst places to be an undocumented immigrant," citing accusations that immigration judges have bullied children and dismissed the claims of people claiming to be domestic abuse victims.Will Miller, a staff attorney with Catholic Charities, which provides legal services to immigrants, told VICE the abnormally high rate of denials can have a chilling effect on lawyers who would otherwise pursue an asylum case. "I know that when I first started, the general consensus was, 'Don't take asylum cases, because they're just going to be denied, and you're just going to be wasting your client's money.'""When I first started, the general consensus was, 'Don't take asylum cases, because they're just going to be denied.'" — Will Miller
Advertisement
Advertisement
In the recent years, immigration lawyers have banded together to form pro-bono legal networks like the CARA project, which pools resources from several major nonprofit organizations and a national association of attorneys to take on cases in family detention centers in Texas.While that exact model may not translate to Atlanta, where asylum cases are routinely denied in the courtroom, there are other improvements to be made. The city lacks some of the resources that can help take on complex asylum cases and appeals, such as immigration law clinics at local law schools."It is honestly shocking to me that none of the area law schools have been able to invest up until this point in an immigration clinic," said Shana Tabak, a visiting assistant professor who has been teaching asylum law at Georgia State University since last August. Such clinics, an established force in states such as New York and California, allow law students and professors to take on challenging and sometimes unpopular cases, drawing on the resources of the school.In the meantime, Atlanta-area lawyers may also be able to improve the success rate by looking beyond the trial level and focusing on appeals. For victories at the initial trial level, they're fighting for better oversight or even a different set of judges. "A real target that we talked about was over the course of two years, we'd like to see an increase of granted asylum from two percent to thirty percent," said Sarah Owings, a leading member of the local chapter of the the American Immigration Lawyers Association, in an interview with VICE. "I don't know if that's aiming for the moon, I don't know if that's aiming for the roof. I'm not sure yet.""We'd like to see an increase of granted asylum from two percent to thirty percent. I don't know if that's aiming for the moon or aiming for the roof." — Sarah Owings
Advertisement